~~~~~PREFACE~~~~~
Shortly after Donald J. Trump was elected president of the U.S. in 2016, famous pornographer, Larry Flynt, offered ten million dollars to anyone having information leading to Donald’s impeachment. So far, aside from Robert Mueller’s meticulous excavation, nobody has stepped forward. Larry is still in possession of ten million dollars but on November 7th, the House of Representatives flipped to a Democratic majority – a game changer for Mr. “T.”
And although, Larry Flynt’s public gesture is null and void, it brought back a personal experience and a cautionary tale that smacks of the “me too” movement. As a young, innocent writer, I was violated on paper, and a wild journey ensued. When I first wrote “Writer Beware,” there were no “met too” conversations, although (as you’ll read), the same offensive behaviors persisted. That’s why this true story deserves telling, especially now. Right now, in fact:
~~~~~MS. WRITER BEWARE~~~~~
A long time ago, women were guilty of saying the oft-used phrase, “men are pigs.” Although I had met some questionable men in my day, I never liked that sentiment. I thought it was a self-fulfilling prophecy. In retaliation, I wrote a freelance opinion piece entitled “Men Are Not Pigs” that was 1,000 words in length. The essay was positive, light and generally delightful. It contained no sexual references and no swear words.
Now however, times have altered inexorably. The current, and highly charged climate of sexual misconduct, Harvey Weinstein’s perp walk, and the “me too” movement, it turns out that “Men Are Not Pigs” was a questionable title. It still is.
As I look back to that era, the phrase, “men are pigs” was uttered casually all the time. And although I had encountered a good number of cheaters, sociopaths and scoundrels, it never sat well with me. Feeling like the phrase could create a self-fulfilling prophecy, and a path to romantic sabotage, I was moved to write an antidote to the questionable philosophy. The essence of my op-ed suggested that women should be careful about lamenting, “men are pigs” ad nauseam because these claims might create a self-fulfilling prophecy. As of today, it DID – become a self-fulfilling prophecy, that is. Oh snap.
Originally, the article came off as pithy, funny, positive, and very pro-male. Almost immediately, with beginner’s luck, I sold it for $400. When a brand new start-up magazine put out a call for essays on relationship issues, I submitted the piece. As a secretary to a television producer, I was a “wannabe” writer, which made selling this piece immediately, a living dream.
When the young (male) editor called me, he said, “Wow. You can really write. You write like a veteran. What else do you have?” His warm, friendly and encouraging call infused me with a tsunami of endorphins and dopamine. It was an enormous breakthrough. He wanted more articles!! The writer’s block spell seemed to have run its course, and I was reborn. I was ecstatic and relieved because it seemed as though my writing career was launched (or was it lynched?) There was cause for celebration. Uncork the Crystal.
I was CERTAIN that this sale signaled the launch of a career just like that of Carrie Bradshaw, Carrie Fisher or a funny Joan Didion. It didn’t. Without an agent or attorney, I naively signed a one-page agreement. When the $400 check cleared, I exhaled. In rarified territory, I was now a paid writer. Wahoo. Waiting for the premiere issue to debut, my plan was to purchase numerous copies of the new magazine and tell all my friends. Hallelujah.
There’s a twist to my literary fairytale, but you knew that.
As it turned out the magazine about “relationships,” was owned by Larry Flynt. The same Larry Flynt, who is both a successful pornographer, the subject of a motion picture, and heroic champion of our First Amendment rights. When the editor sent me a complimentary copy of the brand new, start-up magazine (which must remain nameless), I excitedly tore open the large brown envelope and quickly skimmed the contents – at which time, an electrical shock of tsunami proportions coursed through my entire torso. This was the moment when I discovered that the magazine was not about relationships. Instead, the rag-mag was 100% USDA pornography. And let me be clear. It was not soft porn – it was graphic and hard-core.
Every other page depicted spreads of coiffed designer vaginas and nuclear sized, erect cocks with bulging blue veins. In addition, my clever, PG-rated article, “Men Are Not Pigs,” preceded two pages of 1-800-955-3434 (thumbnail size) “come fuck me” advertisements.
This was my very first sale as an aspiring writer. And although I felt crushed, it actually got worse. The young, all male, crackerjack editorial staff rewrote my frothy essay and turned it into X-rated, pond scum. They transformed the article into lewd, violent images with racial insults. “Men are Not Pigs” went from being a light-hearted “romp” to first person, raunchy smut. Those boys changed everything, except my name.
The following excerpts are a few samples of their Pulitzer Prize-winning, re-write:
“Suddenly, I found myself facedown in another woman’s pussy.” (With no offense to the LGBT community, I have never found myself “face down” in another woman’s pussy. Many of my friends HAVE, however – found themselves there). Another fabrication: “They passed me around like day-old pizza.” (Inferring that I was a willing participant in a gang-bang).
When I decided to battle Larry Flynt Publications legally, it became a quintessential, David VS Goliath set up. Officially, it was considered an “intellectual property” case. That Larry Flynt’s name and “intellectual property” could end up in the same sentence was and IS another irony.
Through friends of friends, I wrangled a C-level lawyer on a contingency basis, which means if I didn’t receive a settlement, he would not receive a settlement. My C-level attorney, an unwashed version of Nick Nolte, was just as funky and low class as the situation itself. The dude’s Santa Monica office was decorated with a bicycle, basketballs, one skateboard, tennis balls, a desk, some socks in the corner, and some weird incense, it smelled like a gym. Essentially, it was a frat house, dorm room. This Nolte knockoff did have a law degree but most importantly, he was free. There were no charges. I suspect that he heard the name, “Larry Flynt,” and envisioned immediate payout.
When the day of legal reckoning arrived, I met Nolte downtown at the Los Angeles County Courthouse to hear the judge’s decision. The judge was a plump, middle-aged blond woman who looked like Betty White. She looked like a sweet woman, and I felt elated. Surely, she’d align with my case. With glasses halfway down her nose, she scanned our filing and responded quickly.
Judge Betty: “This is a very interesting case (pause). The plaintiff did sign a one-page agreement, and I could be wrong – I could, but I must side with the defendant.” Then she looked up at me, “You might consider filing an appeal. Good luck.”
Wait. It gets worse. Walking out of the courthouse, I reflected out loud to Nick.
Me: “I wonder just how they can turn PG-rated material into porn?”
Nolte: “It’s a good question. I don’t do appellate work. Best of luck.”
WHAT??? In a nano-second, a judge and my attorney dumped me on hot pavement and wished me luck. It was a whiplash moment.
Over the course of several weeks following my loss, I faxed several attorneys about filing an appeal. By this time, I was losing steam. It seemed insurmountable that anyone worth his or her salt professionally would take my case. When I did not hear back from any of the appellate attorneys, I decided to give up and chalk the whole thing up to experience. I took a deep breath and went about the business of living life again. I began to put Flynt in my rear-view mirror and move on.
And then one day, my phone rang. It was a high-profile law firm, interested in my case. They were enthusiastic about filing an appeal. An attorney left me a message that said, “Your case is very compelling. Please give me a call.” But by this time, I was exhausted, disheartened and turned off. Looking back, I wish I had persevered.
Within a month of the judge’s ruling, I received an invoice for $250 from one Flynt’s lawyers. Because I had lost to the billionaire, this letter requested reimbursement for his Mr. Flynt’s filing fees – perfectly legal. On a meager secretary’s salary, I was horrified. Without giving it much thought, and with great naïveté, I called the number on the invoice and was connected to one of Flynt’s lawyers on the phone immediately. Don’t ask me why the guy took my call, but he did. This is how it went:
Me: “Hi Mr. Blum. This is Carrie Freeman. I just lost the intellectual property case with your client, Mr. Flynt? You remember?”
Blum: “Oh yeah. How are you? What can I do for you?”
Me: “ It’s about the requested $250 in filing fees. May I be frank?”
Blum: “Of course.”
Me: Listen, you and I both know that two hundred and fifty dollars are pocket change to Mr. Flynt. You’re not REALLY going to make a secretary write you a check are you?”
This attorney either took pity on me or was shocked at my gall. Without any fanfare, he said, “That’s fine.”
Totally shocked, I thanked him. It was so easy. But since I had him on the phone, I went further. Me: “Now that’s it’s over, may I ask you one question?”
Blum: “Sure.”
Me: “How do you figure that it’s OK for a PG-rated article to be turned into X-rated, violent and racially offensive material without the permission of the author?”
Silence. Blum finally replied, “Good question. You should go into law.”
After “Men Are Not Pigs” was bastardized, I did not write again for well over ten years. Eventually, I defrosted from the literary assault, however – wrote two books and set up a blog site.
“Writer Beware” is a cautionary tale. It posits that writers must beware and be aware. All writers know that every single event is fodder for a story, and this was no different. Although the experience was lousy and shocking, I also knew it was a darkly funny and ironic. I saw the humor then, and I see the humor now.
LOG LINE: Girl writes a fluff piece called Men Are Not Pigs and a male editor transforms it into pure porn.
~~~~~EPILOGUE~~~~~
You would think that I dislike Larry Flynt, but I don’t. I like that Mr. Flynt is a self-made man who knows more about the First Amendment than our current president. And I really appreciate that Larry Flynt is on the blue side of politics. When the Democrats take the house on November 7, 2018, Flynt’s patriotic offer of ten million will be null. Instead, expect the Democratic Party and Bob Mueller to stalk Trump like the crocodile stalked Captain Hook in the tale of Peter Pan. Tick tock. Tick tock.
And even though my Writer Beware experience was exhausting and humiliating, I actually do not believe that all men are pigs – only some – like the ones who wear red ties and drink lots of beer. Writer Beware.